Sunday, November 15, 2026

Letters to Malcom: Letter 6 (Part 4)

To this point Lewis has been considering the statements of Alec Vidler have "less religion" in Christianity assuming an action-based definition of "religion". However, certainly religion can also be defined by a system of beliefs. It is here that Vidler desires to minimize by testing religious doctrines to see if that have been outgrown. Lewis appears quite skeptical and certainly sarcastic in addressing Vidler's plan. Of course, Vidler is not the only person, nor is Christianity the only religion, in which a plan to test the religion has been suggested.  

I am not going to address the challenge of how to define a religion's core system of beliefs or even what should be done about people who do not believe them. I am more interested in understanding how a test like that suggested by Vidler would be administered. Vidler, as others before and after him, had trust that the Holy Spirit would provide appropriate guidance in this regard. Perhaps Vidler was counting on some sort of prophetic guidance in which the Holy Spirit spoke to him face-to-face and told him what doctrines were now outgrown, but more likely, Vidler was counting on something like instinct or external moral law to determine what should be discarded. Of course, there may be some sort of majority vote involved, but still each individual is still trusting instinct or using something else as a yardstick with which to measure religion.

It is here that Lewis' Abolition of Man comes to the fore. In that work Lewis defines what he names the Tao, the universal morals and truths that appear to animate all religions. To test religious doctrines, one would be forced to utilize one part of the Tao to disregard another. This causes the system to fall upon itself leading to moral chaos that eventually concludes with the whims of the elite. 

Now, one may argue that this is not at all what Vidler had in mind. The Tao spans religions and what Vidler would like to test are the doctrines of the religion, not its moral truths. For example, in Christianity one might argue that the concept of the virgin birth can be removed without changing its morals and ethics. After all, there are other religions that adhere to the Tao and do not feature a virgin birth. The challenge with doing so is that Christianity (and other religions in their own way) build morals off of beliefs. To not do so, to simply say the Tao is natural law without beliefs, would then undermine the Tao completely, putting us back where we started.
 
In Judaism, a law-based religion, the issue can be taken a step further. Many Jews throughout the ages have attempted to demonstrate the anachronism of various laws, arguing that they have been outgrown, or do not adhere to modern ethics. This in its own way undermines the Tao. For while there are certainly laws that no longer apply (for example the laws related to the Temple service) that does not take away from their role in forming the basis of the Tao. Hence our Sages (Ta'anis 27b), interpreting the verse in Hosea (14:3), have insisted that reading the order of the sacrifices is as is one brought the sacrifices. Though the sacrifices are not actually brought, the values and ethics of Jewish society still rests on those laws as well.  

Hence Lewis' opposition to the Vidler's plan. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Letters to Malcom: Letter 6 (Part 4)

To this point Lewis has been considering the statements of Alec Vidler  have "less religion" in Christianity assuming an action-ba...